Teaching Mama

playing, creating, and learning at home

Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

facebook twitter pinterest instagram googleplus email bloglovin
  • Home
  • About
    • Disclosure
    • Privacy Policy
    • Meet the Team
  • Baby
  • Toddlers
    • Sensory Play
    • Fine Motor Skills
    • Gross Motor Skills
    • Toys
  • Preschoolers
    • Homeschooling
    • Alphabet
      • Printable Alphabet Packets
    • Fine Motor Skills
    • Gross Motor Skills
    • Math
    • Music
    • Reading
      • Book Activities
    • Science
    • Technology
  • Motherhood
    • Thoughts on Life
    • Faith
    • Parenting
  • Contact
  • My Store
    • Your Account
    • Cart
    • Checkout
  • Course

Why Letter of the Week Curriculum Isn’t Effective

by Angela Thayer 7 Comments

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links to Amazon. For more information, please see my disclosure.

Do you use Letter of the Week curriculum? I’ve used it in the past and while it does have some benefits, it’s not my first choice.

The concept is great…children will learn a letter every week and then at the end of 26 weeks, they will know all the alphabet letters! But the reality is, most children aren’t going to magically know the alphabet letters after 26 weeks. In my opinion, Letter of the Week (LOTW) curriculum isn’t effective.

Why letter of the week curriculum is not effective

Children learn from repeated exposure over time and they learn at their own pace. It doesn’t always happen in a straight line as we want it to.

After reading a book called No More Teaching a Letter a Week by Rebecca McKay and William H. Teale, it really convinced me that there was a more effective way to teach kids. (I highly recommend reading this short book if you are interested in learning more!)

I know LOTW curriculum is really popular. In the book, they said that an online search of this reveals 144 million sites that offer resources that teach this.

Before I go any further, I want to say I’m not writing this post to make you feel bad if you do use this method, I’m writing it to reveal an alternative to Letter of the Week curriculum. After writing about this to my email subscribers, I had so many responses from wonderful teachers and they shared what they do in the classroom. Many of them use LOTW curriculum, but supplement with more activities. If you only do a short lesson on each letter each week, with no review over the letters, then you may want to rethink your strategy.

Why Letter of the Week Isn’t Effective

1. The instruction is too isolated

Usually, a LOTW curriculum spends a week teaching one letter using things like songs, crafts, worksheets, books, and themed snacks. For example, if it was a week for letter B, you may do a bear craft, read books about bears, create a snack that looks like a bear, etc.

A lot of LOTW curriculum quickly goes through letters. They may only have one week per letter and don’t spend a lot of time reviewing. For some children, they only need to be taught one time and this works great, but for most kids, they need repeated practice learning letters.

2. The activities are cute but time-consuming

I’m sure you’ve seen or used cute letter crafts, but do they really teach children letters? I’m sure it does help some kids recognize letters and works on fine motor skills, but for how much time it takes to prepare the materials (especially for an entire class), I don’t think it’s worth it. In my opinion, it’s a lot of work for not much return. If you love these types of crafts and have time, then you go for it. I just believe there are easier and more effective activities.

3. Not every letter requires the same instructional attention

Some letters have multiple sounds, are harder to recognize or learn to write and need more time on it. Most kids can recognize O, B, X, and A, but when it comes to lowercase letters b and d, it’s more challenging.

There shouldn’t be just one week per letter. Instead, I believe teaching multiple letters in cycles and spending more time on more challenging letters.

Learning the alphabet is not always easy: the English alphabet comprises forty different shapes! That’s a lot for kids to learn!

learning the alphabet

Alternatives to Letter of the Week Activities:

I used Letter of the Week curriculum with my two oldest boys in preschool. It’s all I knew how to do, so I figured it worked. When I realized the letters weren’t really sticking with them, I switched it up and used multisensory activities to help them learn the letter and sounds. That’s when it began to stick with my kids. They didn’t do well with worksheets, they needed sensory play, games, and hands-on activities.

In the book, No More Teaching a Letter a Week, researchers examined learning letter names and found these conclusions:

  1. A child is very interested in learning the letters that make up their own name.
  2. When learning letters in alphabetical order, children are able to recognize the first half of the alphabet more easily than the second half.
  3. If a child knew their uppercase letters, they were sixteen times more likely to know the lowercase of that same letter. (Especially if the lowercase appearance was similar to the uppercase letter.)
  4. Research tells us there’s no one perfect sequence of instruction for alphabet knowledge.

Here are some ideas for teaching the letters with a multisensory approach:

  • sensory bins – this one is AWESOME and there are so many ideas! You could just fill a bin with rice, add in some magnetic alphabet letters and have your child find the letters.
  • tactile letter cards – having kids FEEL the shape of the letter helps them with identifying and learning how to write the letters. I’ve done homemade cards and used sandpaper letters.
  • writing trays – spread salt in a tray and practice writing and identifying alphabet letters
  • alphabet books – there are so many awesome books focused on letters
  • alphabet chart – on an anchor chart, write an alphabet letter at the top. Then ask your students to identify items in the room that begin with that letter. Write them down and as you write it, draw students’ attention to the initial sounds. (i.e. D-d-d-door. What sound do you hear at the beginning of door?)

I wrote a preschool curriculum called Home Preschool Made Easy and it is an alternative to using Letter of the Week curriculum. This allows children to learn alphabet letters, math concepts, motor skills, the arts and more through a variety of activities.

Home Preschool Made Easy

Instead of teaching one letter per week, you teach alphabet letters in cycles so they get repeated exposure.

Here’s how the curriculum is set up:

1st cycle – learn uppercase letter names (in alphabetical order)

2nd cycle – introduce writing uppercase letters, starting with the easiest ones to write

first- L F E H T I (straight lines)

second – U C O Q G S J D P B R (curved lines)

third – K A M N V W X Y Z (slanted lines)

3rd cycle – learn lowercase alphabet letters, starting with easiest ones

first – c o s v w t (like their capitals)

second – a d g (high-frequency letters and starts with ‘c’ formation)

third – u i e l k y j

fourth – p r n m h b (starts with line down)

fifth – f q x z

4th cycle – introduce letter sounds

first – b d j k p t y z (sound at beginning of letter name)

second – f l m n r x (sound at end of the name)

third – h q w y (no letter name – letter association)

fourth – c g s (more than one sound)

fifth – a e i o u (long and short vowel sounds)

Learning the child’s name is a big focus of the curriculum and the first week of lessons begins with this.

Home Preschool Made Easy
I’ve designed this with homeschooling parents in mind, but this can also be used in the classroom. Check out more details here.
What are your thoughts on this? Do you use a Letter of the Week curriculum? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!

Related Posts

  • Spring Preschool PacketSpring Preschool Packet
  • Sight Word Reader for the Word “Did”Sight Word Reader for the Word “Did”
  • Friday Favorites – Our Labor Day WeekendFriday Favorites – Our Labor Day Weekend
  • Color Matching GameColor Matching Game
  • Fine Motor Skills Colors Game {guest post}Fine Motor Skills Colors Game {guest post}
  • Snow Hot Chocolate {Dramatic Play}Snow Hot Chocolate {Dramatic Play}

Sharing is caring!

796shares
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Filed Under: Alphabet

Comments

  1. Diana Macaluso says

    July 23, 2020 at 10:32 am

    Hi!
    My name is Diana Macaluso and I recently read this book and was so inspired to change up my alphabet curriculum. I am currently teaching 3’s and 4’s in Queens, NY and this will be my third year teaching.I am working on developing my own curriculum and love the way you set up your cycles as they just make a lot on sense. I am curious as to how you would implement your cycles though. For example, the first cycle is to recognize uppercase letter names in alphabetical order. Would you still move on to the next cycle if students have not fully mastered letter recognition? Also, as a teacher would you do a letter a day for each student depending on need or would you designate a day to one letter and only the students who need instruction with that letter would meet in small groups?

    Thanks for your article and your advice!
    Hope you and your family is doing well and is staying safe.
    Diana Macaluso

    Reply
    • Angela Thayer says

      July 27, 2020 at 2:51 pm

      Hi Diana! Thanks for your comment. I’m glad you agree with teaching letters in cycles. There is review time built into this curriculum, so some days you review over letters a child is struggling with. I like your idea of teaching letters in small groups to those who need it. That’s one of the many challenges of teaching…kids are at different levels! So yes, I would meet in small groups. I truly believe kids need many multi-sensory activities to help them learn the alphabet.

      Reply
  2. KAREN says

    August 14, 2020 at 7:41 am

    Thank you for sharing. I am a teacher in Junior High, so I am not into this anymore, but I have a kindergartener at home. As a mom, I always love to see my kid writing but he experiences difficulty. Glad that I have come this page. I will use the cycle format that you have presented here.
    KAREN recently posted…21 Best Gifts for Children with Autism in 2020My Profile

    Reply
  3. Jen says

    August 30, 2020 at 10:25 am

    Is this curriculum appropriate for a 2.5 year old? I don’t expect him to be writing letters or anything at the end, but I’m looking for early learning exposure in an at-home setting. I started planning my own “letter of the week” curriculum before I came across your site and your philosophy/pedagogy really makes more sense to me!

    Reply
    • Angela Thayer says

      September 10, 2020 at 2:47 pm

      I recommend my curriculum for ages 3.5-5. I would do play-based learning with a 2.5 year old or simple activities to expose him to letters and numbers. You can try my curriculum and do the parts that are developmentally appropriate for him. Hope that helps!

      Reply
  4. Lindsay says

    October 24, 2020 at 9:54 pm

    Hello! I love the way you have organized the Alphabet portion of this curriculum. It makes so much sense to teach the letters and sounds in these intentional groupings/cycles! I will be teaching a preschool student, but only 2 days a week. Could we primarily use the alphabet portion of this curriculum and do the other activities as time allows? Is the alphabet portion able to be separated from the week easily or would we need to do all the activities to cover the letters/sounds for the week?

    Reply
    • Angela Thayer says

      December 2, 2020 at 4:40 pm

      Yes! You could definitely do that. You can separate the alphabet portion from the other activities very easily.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




CommentLuv badgeShow more posts
about teaching mama
sensory play crafts printables fall winter spring summer

Search Teaching Mama

Archives

Copyright © 2021 Teaching Mama · Privacy Policy · Disclosure

Copyright © 2021 · Teaching Mama on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

796shares
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkRead more